Using I-Messages for Gentle Communication

How to express what we want by beginning with “I,” rather than blaming the other person with statements beginning with “you,” when we feel upset.

undefined

“I told you to wash your cup after using it.”
“Oh, I forgot.”
“How many times do I have to tell you?”
“People forget sometimes. Why are you making such a big deal out of it?”
“You always make excuses. You never do anything right!”

Everyone has their own values and needs, so dissatisfaction and frustration naturally arise when we live together. We are especially likely to experience such uncomfortable feelings in our relationships with family members—for example, because of a spouse’s habits or a child’s behavior that falls short of our expectations. The problem is that when such situations arise, we are often quick to criticize the other person.

Criticism attacks a person by pointing out their faults or shortcomings and implying that something is wrong with their character or personality. Expressing dissatisfaction with a particular situation is a complaint; when the focus shifts from the situation to the person, it becomes criticism.

According to research on marital happiness, what directly damages a relationship is not personality differences or financial difficulties, but criticism. In fact, criticism is identified as the first thing we should avoid in order to maintain a healthy relationship. This is true not only in marriage but in every kind of relationship. Criticism can be devastating in any relationship because it wounds the person on the receiving end, and the deeper the hurt, the harder it may be to recover.



Criticism Speaks in You-Messages



Criticism often takes the form of “you + a negative statement,” as in, “You never do anything right.” This way of speaking, which uses “you” as the subject, is called a “you-message.” When we begin with “You” and follow it with a negative judgment, we shift the focus from what the person did to who they are.

Of course, some actions do deserve criticism. However, most issues that lead to conflict within families arise not from behavior that is clearly unethical or immoral, but from differences in lifestyle or values. When others judge us negatively and define who we are on the basis of such differences, it is only natural for us to react defensively.

Moreover, criticism and fault-finding are often accompanied by sweeping generalizations such as “all the time,” “always,” “too much,” and “never.” The listener is unlikely to agree with such statements and may focus on the exaggeration rather than the issue itself. This is often why a conversation unintentionally escalates into serious conflict.

Verbal abuse, including criticism, may be dismissed as insignificant because it leaves no visible scars. However, when it continues over time, it does more than cause emotional distress; it can lead to measurable changes in the brain. Research led by Martin Teicher of Harvard Medical School has linked childhood maltreatment, including verbal abuse, to reduced hippocampal volume and structural changes in the corpus callosum in adulthood. Such changes may contribute to difficulties in social functioning as well as increased anxiety and depression.

When people are repeatedly subjected to negative judgments from those around them, they may become increasingly withdrawn and eventually begin to behave in ways that conform to those judgments. This is known as the stigma effect. In other words, criticism may actually make people more likely to continue the very behavior for which they are being criticized. Criticism therefore not only damages relationships but also causes the person on the receiving end to become emotionally closed off. Once that happens, it becomes difficult to expect any meaningful change in behavior.



The Unmet Need behind Criticism



Criticism often comes out almost reflexively when we feel upset by something another person says or does. When we are overwhelmed by negative emotions, we naturally slip into using you-messages and may criticize the other person without even realizing it. Therefore, to work through a conversation without hurting the other person, we must learn to manage the negative emotions that arise when we find their words or behavior difficult to accept.

We criticize because we are convinced that the problem lies with the other person. Beneath that conviction, however, is our own desire for them to change. Although it may seem that the other person has caused our frustration, we need to recognize that those feelings actually stem from what we want or expect of them. If we had no particular expectations of the other person, we would not be so troubled by what they said or did. Criticism, then, is a misguided expression of an unmet need.

When we feel upset, we should pause before blaming the other person. We should ask ourselves what is making us uncomfortable, whether the discomfort is truly too much to bear, and whether it is something worth bringing up. If we believe that expressing our discomfort could improve the situation, we must separate the person from the problem. We should remember that the source of our discomfort is not the person themselves but something they have said or done, and express what we would like them to do instead of criticizing them.

Conversely, if someone becomes angry and pours out words of criticism and blame, we can respond more effectively than reacting emotionally. We can calmly tell them that their words and actions may be hurtful to us. Though it is not easy, we should also try to understand the message behind their criticism. Even when that message comes wrapped in harsh words, there may be an underlying need they are trying to express. By recognizing that need and asking, “Is this what you mean?” we show that we are willing to understand and acknowledge their concerns. This can help calm them down and prevent the conversation from falling into a recurring cycle of criticism.



Using I-Messages to Express What You Want



Because family members are so close, situations that make us uncomfortable with one another are bound to arise. To communicate smoothly without criticizing one another, we need to learn effective ways of expressing ourselves. After all, many conflicts arise from how we express ourselves rather than from the issue itself. American psychologist Dr. Thomas Gordon introduced “I-messages” as a communication technique for handling conflict constructively. An I-message uses “I” as the subject to express how we feel and what we think about another person’s behavior. For example, we might say, “When you leave your cup unwashed, I feel as though you are leaving it for me to wash, and that bothers me. I’d like you to wash it right after using it.”

Using an I-message makes communication safer because it avoids judging, interpreting, or reprimanding the other person. As a result, it is less likely to make them defensive or hurt their feelings. By talking about what we have seen and heard, how we feel, and what we want, we can communicate honestly and openly. This fosters a cooperative rather than argumentative atmosphere and keeps the focus on the behavior, not the person.

A statement that uses “you” to criticize the other person and one that uses “I” to express what we want could not be more different. A you-message vents our anger at the other person, whereas an I-message helps them understand us. The two convey entirely different messages and emotions to the listener, which can in turn change how they feel and respond.

When a conversation begins to grow heated, using an I-message can help prevent it from turning into an argument. Whenever we are about to begin a sentence with “You,” we can try changing the subject to “I.” However, because the ultimate purpose of an I-message is to show consideration for the other person and communicate harmoniously, the words that follow “I” must also be gentle. Even if we use the form of an I-message, statements such as “I’m angry” or “I don’t want to talk to you” are ineffective if they still sound aggressive or negative to the listener. As we learn to use I-messages properly and put them into practice, we begin to temper our harsh thoughts and manage our emotions more effectively.



◆ ◆ ◆



Criticism can wound the listener, but it also has a harmful effect on the person giving it. Although criticizing someone may seem to relieve stress, it actually increases the release of stress hormones in the body. When repeated, it can reinforce negative patterns of thought, making it more difficult to think and speak positively. In other words, when we criticize others, we also pay a price ourselves.

Criticism is hurtful in itself, but the pain can be even greater when it comes from a family member. When we need to express discomfort to someone in our family, we should set criticism aside and use an I-message. You-messages, meanwhile, can be used positively to convey care and affection: “You are precious,” “You have such a beautiful heart,” or “What do you think?” We can also use “we” as the subject. Questions such as “What should we eat?” or “How should we solve this problem?” create a sense of unity and show that we are willing to consider the other person’s opinion.

What matters most is the heart behind our words. As long as we continue to respect the other person, even in difficult situations, we can refrain from criticizing them. Ultimately, using I-messages is a way of learning to recognize and respect others as individuals. When we put away sharp words and choose gentle conversation, we also encourage our own inner growth.